Wikia

Pokémon Wiki

Changes: Forum:Changing the site name

Edit

Back to page

(Staff advice)
Line 14: Line 14:
 
{{comment}} Giving this forum a little nudge. With the information I was given from the community skype channel, that means that we '''can''' get a wiki rename once again. So if I got a bit more input, meaning if there were more supports, I'd be able to run this request through and hopefully get the name changed. &ndash; [[User:Jäzzi|<span style="color:#009DD7;font:9pt 'Century Gothic'">Jazzi</span>]] ([[User talk:Jäzzi|<span style="color:#009DD7;font:9pt 'Century Gothic'">talk</span>]]) 19:15, July 12, 2013 (UTC)
 
{{comment}} Giving this forum a little nudge. With the information I was given from the community skype channel, that means that we '''can''' get a wiki rename once again. So if I got a bit more input, meaning if there were more supports, I'd be able to run this request through and hopefully get the name changed. &ndash; [[User:Jäzzi|<span style="color:#009DD7;font:9pt 'Century Gothic'">Jazzi</span>]] ([[User talk:Jäzzi|<span style="color:#009DD7;font:9pt 'Century Gothic'">talk</span>]]) 19:15, July 12, 2013 (UTC)
 
{{support}} Since Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr have already changed, it's better to keep it consistent. All this is just a part of revitalizing the wiki into something better and I support the change. {{User:Bermuda/sig2|19:45,7/12/2013}}
 
{{support}} Since Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr have already changed, it's better to keep it consistent. All this is just a part of revitalizing the wiki into something better and I support the change. {{User:Bermuda/sig2|19:45,7/12/2013}}
{{oppose}} Hi, I may be a former contributor here but I still do look at the site for information and its following so-to-speak, and have on multiple occasions tried coming back after being shooed away from the administration, but nevertheless, I have finally made my first re-appearance on Wikia since my incident in mid-June...but anyway, as even a person who looks at the wiki's content, as with anyone else on Wikia for that matter, I should be entitled to even a brief say of input here. I noticed this in one of my tabs and was all "no...just...no." Like, really? This is not a good idea at all. For one, the name sounds more similar to your actual competition Bulbapedia, and quite frankly, the current name fits much better with Wikia's consistency. Second, the social network pages should have come '''second''' not done ahead just to get support, you know '''after''' a discussion was reached... In addition, the name was changed before and was changed to what it is now for good reason; why change it back just because "those people don't edit anymore?" That's like changing the name of a country just because the founding fathers are long dead. Changing the name doesn't actually help the community, and as someone who actually uses the site, I think that changing the name would just cause confusion. Just my two cents. '''''[[User:Wattz2000|<span style="color:#1D7074">The</span>]]&nbsp;[[User talk:Wattz2000|<span style="color:#265557">Puzzle</span>]]&nbsp;[[Special:Contributions/Wattz2000|<span style="color:#09484B">Master</span>]]''''' 20:32, July 12, 2013 (UTC)
+
{{oppose}}: Hi, I may be a former contributor here but I still do look at the site for information and its following so-to-speak, and have on multiple occasions tried coming back after being shooed away from the administration, but nevertheless, I have finally made my first re-appearance on Wikia since my incident in mid-June...but anyway, as even a person who looks at the wiki's content, as with anyone else on Wikia for that matter, I should be entitled to even a brief say of input here. I noticed this in one of my tabs and was all "no...just...no." Like, really? This is not a good idea at all. For one, the name sounds more similar to your actual competition Bulbapedia, and quite frankly, the current name fits much better with Wikia's consistency. Second, the social network pages should have come '''second''' not done ahead just to get support, you know '''after''' a discussion was reached... In addition, the name was changed before and was changed to what it is now for good reason; why change it back just because "those people don't edit anymore?" That's like changing the name of a country just because the founding fathers are long dead. Changing the name doesn't actually help the community, and as someone who actually uses the site, I think that changing the name would just cause confusion. Just my two cents. '''''[[User:Wattz2000|<span style="color:#1D7074">The</span>]]&nbsp;[[User talk:Wattz2000|<span style="color:#265557">Puzzle</span>]]&nbsp;[[Special:Contributions/Wattz2000|<span style="color:#09484B">Master</span>]]''''' 20:32, July 12, 2013 (UTC)
{{comment}} We're not changing the name to be like Bulbapedia, and on the "those people don't edit anymore" it was more so a "the people who changed the name in the first place do not edit here any longer we should be able to decide a name for us". And having it be "Pokémon Wiki" just because other wikis on Wikia are "Subject Wiki" is like jumping off a bridge because all your friends are jumping off the bridge. &ndash; [[User:Jäzzi|<span style="color:#009DD7;font:9pt 'Century Gothic'">Jazzi</span>]] ([[User talk:Jäzzi|<span style="color:#009DD7;font:9pt 'Century Gothic'">talk</span>]]) 20:46, July 12, 2013 (UTC)
 

Revision as of 20:48, July 12, 2013

Forums: Index Watercooler Changing the site name

Previously Pokémon Wiki was known as The Pokémon Encyclopedia I was thinking we could change our name back to Pokémon Encyclopedia to welcome in X and Y. The reasoning for this is because we can give the entire site a facelift and changing the site name is part of that. The URL will stay the same, but Pokémon Encyclopedia sounds better. I've changed the Facebook account to focus on the new name. So we might as well change to follow suit with the social networking information. The Twitter and the Tumblr have been re-opened under "Pokémon Encyclopedia", all that needs changing is the wiki name.

Voting

Support Support: As nominator. – Jazzi (talk) 14:59, July 4, 2013 (UTC) Support Support: Shorter, simpler and better. Energy X 15:15, July 4, 2013 (UTC)

Neutral Neutral: I am not too sure about changing the site name to Pokémon Encyclopedia?{{SUBST:User:King Marth 64/Sig}} 16:06, July 4, 2013 (UTC)
Comment Comment: Changing the name would allow the social networks to be synced with the wiki and it just sounds better. – Jazzi (talk) 16:34, July 4, 2013 (UTC)Support Support:The idea is sound in principle and would work very well I think.Markrogers (talk) 19:29, July 4, 2013 (UTC)
Oppose Oppose: Firstly, it sounds like the name has already been changed, and you can only change the site name once. Also, almost all wikis hosted under Wikia are named "The (xyz) Wiki", so why should the Pokémon wiki be any different. We would also need to re-design the wordmark and change a lot of links to the main page (for example, the Pokémon Wiki: namespace will move to The Pokémon Encyclopedia: namespace). Iggyvolz (Talk) 14:09, July 5, 2013 (UTC)
Comment Comment: Site name can be changed. Not all wikis follow that naming convention and they don't all have to be the same. The wordmark doesn't take long to change if you have five minutes. The links are an easy fix. There's really no problem to changing the name, it just takes a few minutes to change the wordmark and an hour or so to fix links. – Jazzi (talk) 15:32, July 5, 2013 (UTC)
Comment Comment: "Please double check the spelling, and be sure of your correction, as we will not honor multiple requests" - Special:Contact/wiki-name-change Iggyvolz (Talk) 15:38, July 5, 2013 (UTC)
Comment Comment: The name was changed back in 2009. The users then no longer edit now. There's a different frame now than there was then. I'm also not sure why you're in a fuss over this if you don't regularly edit here. – Jazzi (talk) 00:53, July 6, 2013 (UTC)
Comment Comment: I have asked in the community skype channel, where staff members can answer questions, and the response was as followed: It is possible, but the request would need to come from an Admin or point us to a community consensus for the site name changing back. Send either to S:C.Jazzi (talk) 14:51, July 6, 2013 (UTC)
Comment Comment: Giving this forum a little nudge. With the information I was given from the community skype channel, that means that we can get a wiki rename once again. So if I got a bit more input, meaning if there were more supports, I'd be able to run this request through and hopefully get the name changed. – Jazzi (talk) 19:15, July 12, 2013 (UTC)

Support Support: Since Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr have already changed, it's better to keep it consistent. All this is just a part of revitalizing the wiki into something better and I support the change. Bermuda • Triangle • 19:45,7/12/2013

Oppose Oppose:: Hi, I may be a former contributor here but I still do look at the site for information and its following so-to-speak, and have on multiple occasions tried coming back after being shooed away from the administration, but nevertheless, I have finally made my first re-appearance on Wikia since my incident in mid-June...but anyway, as even a person who looks at the wiki's content, as with anyone else on Wikia for that matter, I should be entitled to even a brief say of input here. I noticed this in one of my tabs and was all "no...just...no." Like, really? This is not a good idea at all. For one, the name sounds more similar to your actual competition Bulbapedia, and quite frankly, the current name fits much better with Wikia's consistency. Second, the social network pages should have come second not done ahead just to get support, you know after a discussion was reached... In addition, the name was changed before and was changed to what it is now for good reason; why change it back just because "those people don't edit anymore?" That's like changing the name of a country just because the founding fathers are long dead. Changing the name doesn't actually help the community, and as someone who actually uses the site, I think that changing the name would just cause confusion. Just my two cents. The Puzzle Master 20:32, July 12, 2013 (UTC)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki